Hello dear
Welcome To Lucas Brothers Sandwich Shop
Lucas Brothers Sandwich Shop, located in Columbus, Indiana, is a beloved destination for burger enthusiasts. Renowned for their fresh, never frozen, ingredients, they serve up a variety of delectable sandwiches that keep customers returning for more. The standout double patty melt and juicy burgers, complete with crispy fries and perfectly cooked onion rings, have garnered rave reviews for their comforting, nostalgic flavors. The casual atmosphere invites diners to indulge in hearty meals while enjoying the friendly service. Though there may be a wait for the quality, patrons agree: the food is worth every minute.
About
Lucas Brothers Sandwich Shop
Welcome to Lucas Brothers Sandwich Shop, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, Indiana. This cozy eatery, located at 2318 25th St, offers a delightful experience for sandwich lovers and burger enthusiasts alike. When you step inside, the charm of the place instantly warms you, inviting you to indulge in their mouthwatering creations.
Lucas Brothers is renowned for its commitment to serving fresh, high-quality ingredients. As a reviewer, I've been fortunate enough to delve into some of their standout offerings, which genuinely embody the essence of comfort food. Guests rave about the double patty melt, where melted cheese elegantly embraces juicy beef patties, delivering a satisfying taste experience. The grilled chicken sandwich also comes highly recommended, praised for its grill marks and succulent flavor.
What sets Lucas Brothers apart is the attention to detail. Customers have noted that while the food may take up to 20 minutes to prepare, this wait is a testament to their dedication to freshness. One diner, Jessica, expressed that waiting for a freshly grilled burger is preferable to a frozen alternative—a sentiment echoed by many who visit this quaint spot. The onion rings, crispy and seasoned just right, have also received commendations for being the perfect complement to any meal.
Juicy burgers are the stars of the menu, often retaining a flavorful moistness that leaves your palate singing. Wesley Myers described his burger experience as “sweet heavens,” highlighting the perfectly cooked patty and crispy fries that accompanied his meal. This enthusiastic praise underscores the delightful balance of flavors that Lucas Brothers masterfully achieves in each dish.
As you explore the menu, don’t miss out on their famous mushroom gravy burger, which has been hailed as one of Indiana's best. Tyler Hodapp's enthusiastic review captures the burger’s deliciousness perfectly, noting that the staff here make the entire dining experience even more enjoyable. The ambiance, paired with friendly service, creates a welcoming atmosphere where patrons can relax and indulge in culinary delights.
Overall, Lucas Brothers Sandwich Shop is a testament to the belief that food should be made with care. Fresh ingredients, perfectly grilled meats, and a nostalgic vibe make it a worthwhile stop. Whether you decide to call ahead for takeout or dine in, expect to enjoy a meal that satisfies your cravings for hearty, homemade sandwiches and burgers. It’s a spot where flavors come alive, leaving you with memories as rich as the culinary experiences they create.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ We got the double patty melt, grilled chicken sandwich, and onion rings. The food was really greasy, but really good. It took longer than expected, about 20 minutes, for us to get our food after we ordered. I’d rather wait 20 minutes for a fresh burger than get a frozen patty any day. I HATE frozen burgers and these are definitely fresh not frozen. Cute little place. ”
“ sweet heavens this was an incredible burger. perfectly cooked to be nice and juicy, a toasty bun, and the grilled onions were a perfect touch. the fries were also perfectly crispy and hot! my wife is very picky about her burgers and she gave high praise for these, we'll definitely be back! (Also they give you more fries than in the picture, i just couldn't stop eating them before I got the picture. ”
“ Got a mushroom gravy burger n fries the workers were amazing! This is hands down one of the very few killer burgers indiana has to offer. Will be back for a double ”
“ Lucas Burger was so juicy, full of flavor and big value. Fries were like "the old days"! Crisp on the outside, perfect on the inside. Needed more grilled onions. Had ordered double but had very little. Glass between kitchen and dining messy. Staff okay. ”
“ The food is great. It's fresh, so you will wait for it to cook. It's hot and juicy and delicious. The onion rings are the best! Hot, crunchy and just the right amount of salt. You can call in your order if you're in a hurry, or order and sit and relax in the booths. Add your own ketchup and mustard if you want it. The food has the right amount of grease to make it flavorful and tasty. ”
“ The hamburgers are some of the best around, everything was cooked fresh and hot and it can't be beat. I definitely recommend eating here if you are craving an outstanding burger. ”
“ One of if not the best cheese burgers in Columbus. If you haven't been here, it's definitely worth a special trip! ”
“ "What do you want? They've got burgers, pork tenderloins, chicken, grilled cheese, hot dogs, corn dogs ..." "What are you getting?" "Well, I can't pass up a cheeseburger combo with fries and a Coke." "I'll take one of those, too." On behalf of my father-in-law, please allow me to highly recommend the deluxe cheeseburger, the piping hot french fries, and the Coke with a perfect amount of ice. The ketchup is waiting at the table, and the paper towels are ready when the burger and fries get a little messy. Enjoy! ”